Skip to main content

Choose an approach

Machine learning or generative AI: how do you choose?

The short answer

Start with the required output. Forecasting a value or detecting a defect often calls for predictive or classification models. Producing a summary calls for a generative approach. Generative AI is itself part of machine learning.

Four needs, several possible approaches

This guide offers a starting point. The comparison then depends on your data, quality requirements and operating costs.

Four needs, several possible approaches
Your needApproach to examine
Forecast demand or volumesPredictive models and time series, compared with a simple forecast.
Identify a defect in an imageComputer vision and classification, tested on rare defects too.
Summarise documents or prepare meeting minutesGenerative AI, with facts reviewed against the original documents.
Find a specific referenceDocument search or structured data. Add generation if it helps.

Compare on the same cases

Take a representative sample, keep separate cases for testing and define an acceptable result. For forecasts, measure error. For summaries, check facts, omissions and correction time.

A generative model can also classify or extract data. A comparative trial can measure its value against a specialised model on a stable, repeated operation.

The approaches can work together

Design example: a model predicts inventory needs. A generative interface lets the procurement manager query the results and consult the calculation behind each forecast.

Test results indicate whether an existing model fits or needs adapting. Privacy, response time and available hardware also inform the choice from the assessment stage.

For your decision

Test approaches on the same cases, then compare quality, cost and correction time.

Further reading